NSFW

News/Stories/Facts://Written

Voisin U-turn after suggesting workers’ rights take second place

A quiet, well-maintained commercial street in St Helier, Jersey, Channel Islands, on an overcast autumn morning.

In brief: Jersey’s Economic Development Minister, Deputy Gerald Voisin, has said that workers’ rights may need to “take second place” to economic growth, before issuing a clarifying statement walking back the remarks. The comments came as Statistics Jersey figures show the island’s economy fell in real terms by 1.7% in 2025, with further decline expected.

Growth at Any Cost? Voisin Sparks Debate

Deputy Gerald Voisin was speaking after appearing alongside fellow ministers at an Institute of Directors lunch, where the government shared its economic priorities with the business community. Asked by the BBC what he considered a healthy annual growth rate, Voisin was unambiguous: “I think we should be targeting a 3% growth.” Getting there, he warned, would require “difficult decisions.”

The remarks that lit the fuse were these: “We are going to have to make decisions that some people may feel hinders other objectives, for example workers’ rights. I mean, it’s very nice to be able to give workers greater rights but if it’s doing that at the cost of economic growth, then I think it has to take second place for the time being.”

Voisin also called for a greater appetite for risk and a rebalancing of “the scales of risk and reward for businesses,” adding that “the big businesses of tomorrow are probably the small businesses of today.” It is the sort of pro-enterprise language that would not sound out of place in a Thatcher-era budget speech, and in the context of a shrinking economy, it is not without logic.

The Pushback: Unions and Reform Jersey Respond

The reaction was swift. James Turner, Unite’s regional officer for Jersey, called it “particularly distasteful for any workers’ rights to be impacted for the sake of economic growth,” pointing out that Jersey’s workers already enjoy fewer protections than their counterparts in the UK and Europe. Turner argued that paying workers a living wage “actually boosts the economy” and called for strong anti-discrimination laws, tribunal awards and parental leave rights to ensure a fair system rather than one “weighted purely for business profits.”

Deputy Montfort Tadier, co-leader of Reform Jersey, described Voisin’s comments as “unfortunate,” arguing that they “unnecessarily pit workers’ rights against businesses.” Tadier insisted the two are not mutually exclusive, and that economic growth must “act in the interests of all islanders.” He pointed to the squeeze felt not just by the lowest paid but by “middle Jersey,” people who are “struggling when it comes to the end of the month.”

The Clarification: A Rapid Reverse Gear

By 4pm on Thursday, Voisin had issued a written statement that amounted to a considerable softening of his earlier position. “I want to make clear that I do not believe economic growth should ever come at the expense of workers’ rights. These are fundamental protections and I am not proposing a reduction in existing workers’ rights,” he said.

He reframed his original comments as being about “the lack of growth Jersey has experienced in recent years” and the need to find “the right balance when it considers adding new regulations to the statute book,” rather than stripping back existing protections. Planning Minister Sir Mark Boleat added his voice, stating that there was “no attempt or no wish to remove any regulation that’s going to jeopardise health and safety or workers’ rights.”

The economic backdrop makes the debate more than academic. According to Statistics Jersey, the island’s economy fell in real terms by 1.7% in 2025, and experts who advise the government said this summer that they expected a further fall. Against that backdrop, the pressure on ministers to find a credible growth strategy is entirely understandable, even if the messaging around it has proved rather less polished.

Source: BBC News

Latest from NSFW