In brief: Jersey’s External Relations Minister, Senator Ian Gorst, has told a scrutiny hearing that the British Airways Heathrow link is so vital to Jersey’s economy that he would support using the island’s competitiveness fund to subsidise it. The debate echoes a live controversy in Guernsey, where public funding for a BA Heathrow service has sparked a bitter row over the future of the island’s own airline, Aurigny.
Gorst Makes the Case for Subsidising Heathrow
Speaking at a scrutiny hearing, Senator Ian Gorst left little room for ambiguity. The Heathrow link, he said, is not merely convenient: it is critical. Guernsey Press reports that the External Relations Minister told the hearing he had been “absolutely clear” with Ports of Jersey that British Airways and the Heathrow connection were essential to the island’s economic future, adding that an evening late rotation from Jersey to the UK year-round was equally non-negotiable.
Going further, Gorst indicated he was prepared to put public money where his mouth is. “I believe it’s so critical that if Ports of Jersey need financial support to deliver and maintain those, then I’m prepared and think it’s the right use for the competitiveness fund to support them,” he said. He added that Ports of Jersey and the Economic Development Minister were “perfectly aligned” on the issue.
The competitiveness fund is, in principle, designed to help Jersey hold its own in an increasingly competitive global environment. Whether bankrolling a legacy carrier’s slot at one of the world’s busiest airports qualifies as a sharp use of that fund is a question Jersey taxpayers may reasonably want answered.
Guernsey’s Cautionary Tale
Gorst’s comments come against the backdrop of a rather turbulent situation just across the water. Guernsey has already gone down the road of publicly subsidising a British Airways Heathrow service, and the results have been, to put it diplomatically, complicated.
According to Guernsey Press, Aurigny, Guernsey’s state-owned airline, has pointed partly to the subsidised BA Heathrow route as a contributor to its financial losses, alongside picking up services from the collapsed Blue Islands and rising fuel costs. The Guernsey Aviation Action Group, however, is having none of it. GAAG chairman Barry Cash argued that Aurigny had itself removed Gatwick capacity from the market by selling its Embraer jet, reducing daily Gatwick seats from around 620 to approximately 420. The BA Heathrow service, he noted, adds roughly 140 seats a day, still leaving total capacity below what Aurigny previously offered on its own.
“They cannot complain because another operator is filling a need they created themselves by selling the jet,” Cash said pointedly.
Garin Dart, chairman of the Confederation of Guernsey Industry, offered a broader critique of how the subsidy decision was handled. He argued that the fundamental question of what Aurigny should actually be delivering for the community should have been settled before any subsidy was handed out. His suggested model is refreshingly straightforward: let Aurigny focus on lifeline routes, keep a spare aircraft for technical cover, and allow commercial operators such as BA and easyJet to serve holiday destinations. Under that model, he suggested, Aurigny could break even without the current confusion over competing subsidised services.
What This Means for Jersey
Ports of Jersey manages the airport as a commercial entity, and the island has historically relied on commercial carriers to maintain its London connections. The question Gorst’s comments raise is whether a competitiveness fund designed to support Jersey’s broader economic position is the right vehicle for propping up a specific air route, however important that route undoubtedly is.
The Heathrow link matters enormously to Jersey’s finance industry, to business travellers, and to the island’s connectivity with global markets. Few would dispute that. The more interesting debate is whether a direct subsidy is the most efficient mechanism, or whether there are smarter structural arrangements that could secure the route without creating the kind of ongoing dependency that has caused such friction in Guernsey.
Source: guernseypress.com



