In brief: Gama Aviation’s bid to subject the Channel Islands’ air ambulance contract award to judicial review has been dismissed by Jersey’s Royal Court. The company, which had provided the service for six years, lost the contract to rival 247 Aviation and argued the procurement process was flawed. A similar challenge in Guernsey was also rejected.
The Challenge That Couldn’t Get Airborne
Gama Aviation, which has operated the Channel Islands’ air ambulance service for the past six years, found itself grounded in court this week after its application for judicial review of the contract award was dismissed. The Jersey Evening Post reports that the Royal Court’s decision was delivered to Gama, 247 Aviation and the Health Department on Tuesday, with a written judgement to follow at a later date.
The case centred on a tender exercise in which 247 Aviation beat out Gama for the new contract, which 247 is due to take up in January 2027. Gama argued that changes to the contract specifications during the bidding process had handed its rival a “decisive competitive advantage”, and that the process contained procedural shortcomings serious enough to warrant the court’s scrutiny.
In a statement, Gama noted the significance of the step it had taken: “This is the first time in our 43-year history that we have challenged a procurement decision through the courts.” The company added that it was disappointed by the outcome and would consider an appeal.
The Aircraft Specifications Row
At the heart of Gama’s argument was a dispute over aircraft engine requirements. During the two-day Royal Court hearing on 4 and 5 November, Gama’s representative, Advocate Jonathan Barham, told the court that stage two of the bidding process had specified that the Jersey service must be provided by twin-engined aircraft. Gama had prepared its bid on that basis. However, Advocate Barham argued that by the time stage three documentation was issued to bidders on 1 April this year, the specifications had changed to permit single-engined aircraft, though the document also contained conflicting wording on the point.
Gama further argued that the timing of this change was particularly damaging, given that the deadline for bids fell on 20 April and key personnel were on leave over the Easter holidays.
Representing Health Minister Tom Binet, Advocate James Rondel pushed back firmly, describing the procurement process as “robust and professional.” He told the court that the Health Department had made clear on multiple occasions during the bidding process that it welcomed a flexible approach from bidders regarding aircraft type. Crucially, he said that both Gama and 247 Aviation had received the same notification about the specifications, and that this communication had taken place in December 2025, a full 122 days before the final deadline for bids. “All competitors were treated fairly and given a fair crack of the whip,” he said.
The application was heard by the Bailiff, Robert MacRae, sitting with Jurats Ronge and Le Cornu.
Guernsey Reached the Same Conclusion
Jersey’s dismissal follows an identical outcome across the water. Gama had also challenged the Guernsey decision to award the contract to 247 Aviation, seeking to have it quashed on the grounds of fairness and transparency. That argument was rejected by Lieutenant-Bailiff Hazel Marshall, who ruled that Guernsey’s government had not breached its own procurement rules.
With both islands now having rejected Gama’s legal challenges, 247 Aviation appears firmly on course to take over the air ambulance service in January 2027, barring any successful appeal by Gama in Jersey.
Source: Jersey Evening Post



