In brief: A report by Jersey’s Comptroller and Auditor General has found the island’s regulatory system to be complex, fragmented and unable to assure value for money. Regulation has developed reactively and in isolation over time, with potential duplication and gaps. The Government has responded with a new Regulatory Principles Framework, published on 18 November 2026.
A Patchwork of Rules With Nobody in Charge
If you have ever suspected that Jersey’s regulatory landscape was built by committee, over several decades, with nobody talking to anybody else, you would be largely correct. A report by the Comptroller and Auditor General, Lynn Pamment CBE, titled Delivering Effective Regulation, has concluded that Jersey’s regulatory system is complex and fragmented, with insufficient assurance that it delivers value for money.
Channel Eye reports that the audit examined how regulation is designed across a broad sweep of areas, including public services, public health, environmental standards, planning, building standards and economic regulation. Crucially, the report focused on the design of regulation rather than how individual regulatory measures operate in practice.
The findings are not flattering. Regulation in Jersey has developed over time, often reactively and in isolation, resulting in layers of regulation, potential duplication and possible gaps when compared with other jurisdictions. At the time of the audit, there was no established framework for deciding what should be regulated and how, no regular process for reviewing regulatory requirements against current evidence and emerging risks, and no common minimum standards to enable comparisons between regulators or with other jurisdictions.
Perhaps most striking is the question of leadership. Responsibility for regulation was fragmented, with no single point of leadership until the appointment of a Minister for Planning and Regulation in July 2026. That is a long time for a jurisdiction that prides itself on being a well-regulated international finance centre to have been operating without anyone clearly at the wheel on domestic regulation.
The Government’s Response: A Framework Arrives
To its credit, the Government has not simply filed the report and moved on. The Council of Ministers approved a new Regulatory Principles Framework, published on 18 November 2026, which Channel Eye describes as Jersey’s first overarching regulatory policy.
The framework introduces six core tests to help policymakers assess whether regulatory proposals are necessary, proportionate and deliverable. It also encourages regular reviews of existing regulations to ensure they remain fit for purpose.
Senator Sir Mark Boleat, Minister for Planning and Regulation, said: “Regulation should be based on clear evidence and a proper understanding of risk. By considering costs, benefits and alternative approaches at an early stage, we can maintain strong protections while avoiding unnecessary complexity and burden.”
Lynn Pamment acknowledged the progress, noting that the appointment of the Minister for Planning and Regulation in July 2026 has provided a single point of regulatory leadership and that the Government is developing an ambitious programme to introduce an evidence-based framework. She added that this represents “an opportunity to redefine regulation around the minimum assurance requirements needed to minimise harm and protect the public interest.”
However, the C&AG also noted that, at the time of the audit, a prioritised and timetabled plan had not yet been established, meaning the new Minister has recognised the problem without yet having a concrete roadmap to fix it.
What This Means for Jersey Residents and Businesses
For ordinary Jerseypeople, fragmented regulation might sound like an abstract concern, but the practical implications are real. Inconsistent oversight across areas such as public health, planning and environmental standards means that protections can vary depending on which part of the system you happen to be dealing with. For businesses, particularly smaller ones, overlapping and duplicated regulatory requirements add cost and complexity without necessarily adding safety or quality.
The C&AG’s report makes clear that a more proportionate, targeted, consistent and accountable approach to regulation would benefit both the public interest and those who have to comply with the rules. The new framework, if implemented effectively, offers a genuine opportunity to streamline a system that has grown organically and somewhat haphazardly over many years.
Source: Channel Eye



