In brief: Treasury Minister Senator Alan Maclean has publicly criticised the previous Council of Ministers for diverting £50 million from the Social Security Fund grant to capital projects, calling it “poor practice.” The move was approved in the 2026 Budget and drew criticism at the time from both the Fiscal Policy Panel and backbench States Members. Senator Maclean says he intends to restore the grant to its recommended level by 2030.
A Raid on the Pension Pot
The Social Security Fund is not some abstract government slush fund. It is financed through contributions from employees and employers across Jersey and exists to pay for benefits including short-term incapacity allowance, carer’s allowance and, crucially, old age pensions. So when the previous Council of Ministers decided to trim £50 million from the grant to that fund and redirect it towards capital projects, eyebrows were raised in some very serious quarters.
The Jersey Evening Post reports that the Fiscal Policy Panel described the move at the time as “not prudent,” and veteran backbencher Sir Philip Bailhache thought it sufficiently alarming to bring an amendment to the policy. He lost, 25 votes to 15, but the discomfort was clearly not forgotten.
Now, facing questions from the Corporate Services Scrutiny Panel during a hearing on the 2027 Budget, Senator Maclean has made his own position plain. “The reduction of the grant is not something that I would support or have supported historically,” he told the panel. “I think to use that money for revenue expenditure is poor practice. We may well change that when we have the review, but to have done it in advance of that is something I think was not a good decision at the time.”
Formula, Reviews and the Road to 2030
The grant to the Social Security Fund is not calculated on a whim. Senator Maclean acknowledged that a formula has been in place for around 15 years to determine the recommended level of the grant. The previous Council of Ministers chose to diverge from that formula. A review of the formula is expected to report in early 2027, which makes the timing of the original decision all the more curious: the previous government effectively pre-empted a review that was already in the pipeline.
Senator Maclean was candid that he has not been able to restore the grant to its recommended level for the 2027 Budget, but told the panel his intention is that this will happen by 2030. That is a commitment, though one that future budgets and future ministers will need to honour.
The Scrutiny Panel hearing was chaired by Deputy Lyndsay Feltham, who served as Social Security Minister between January 2024 and June of this year and who, the JEP notes, defended the original decision in the run-up to last year’s Budget debate. Deputy Feltham argued at the time that using the money to support the government’s capital programme and living wage transition plans was a matter of “inter-generational fairness.” Senator Maclean’s comments before her panel represent a fairly pointed rebuttal of that framing.
Preventative Health: The Long Game
The Budget hearing also touched on preventative healthcare spending. Deputy Hilary Jeune pointed out that investment in areas such as tackling child obesity carries evidence of long-term financial savings. Senator Maclean expressed genuine enthusiasm for the principle, while being refreshingly honest about the structural problem it presents.
“The difficulty for Jersey, and for most jurisdictions, is that this type of investment doesn’t really align very well with political cycles,” he said. “You invest in preventative now and it’s going to be beyond the next election, and probably the one beyond that, before you start seeing the benefits.”
It is a rare moment of political candour: acknowledging that the incentive structures of democratic government can work against sensible long-term planning. Senator Maclean said the government is nonetheless “supportive in principle” of the direction the Health Department is taking on the matter.
Source: Jersey Evening Post



