---
title: "Waitress left unable to pay rent after restaurant withheld her wages"
url: https://www.nsfw.info/waitress-unpaid-wages-spice-of-life-tribunal/
published: 2026-11-12T08:00:54+00:00
modified: 2026-11-12T08:00:54+00:00
author: "Chief Editor"
categories: ["Employment"]
image: https://www.nsfw.info/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/waitress-unpaid-wages-spice-of-life-tribunal-1024x572.webp
summary: "A Jersey employment tribunal has ordered St Helier's Spice of Life restaurant to pay £24,667 to a waitress after finding it unlawfully withheld wages and constr"
publisher: NSFW (https://www.nsfw.info)
---

# Waitress left unable to pay rent after restaurant withheld her wages

**In brief:** A St Helier Thai restaurant has been ordered to pay more than £24,000 to a waitress after an employment and discrimination tribunal found it had unreasonably withheld her wages. The Spice of Life restaurant’s conduct left the employee unable to pay her rent and eventually too ill to work. The tribunal also found constructive unfair dismissal.

## Four Months of Work, Almost No Pay

Anna Sabrina Schmiedel had worked at the Spice of Life restaurant in St Helier since August 2017, but her situation deteriorated sharply after a change of ownership at the end of 2025, when Mr Mohammad Sultan Al-Mahmood took over responsibility for her payroll. According to the Jersey Evening Post, the tribunal heard that Ms Schmiedel worked seven days a week for four months, yet received nothing for the entirety of April 2026’s 230.5 hours worked.

Deputy chair Advocate Cyril Whelan described WhatsApp messages exchanged between Ms Schmiedel and Mr Al-Mahmood during March and April 2026 as making “uncomfortable reading”. The messages showed her chasing wages night after night, asking the owner to send money to pay delivery drivers, managing suppliers whose accounts had been placed on stop for unpaid invoices dating back to January, and reporting the day’s takings late into the evenings, all while the owner was away.

March wages were eventually paid late, but only, the tribunal was told, so that Ms Schmiedel could meet her rent. Even then, no return was passed to Revenue Jersey containing her employee contributions, meaning £882.48 in deductions were simply pocketed rather than forwarded to the tax authority.

## The Owner’s Defence Falls Flat

Mr Al-Mahmood told the hearing that he had withheld wages on advice from the Jersey Advisory and Conciliation Service, claiming Ms Schmiedel had worked “unauthorised overtime”. Advocate Whelan was unimpressed. He noted that her contract already accounted for overtime and gave the employer “no right to withhold pay while a query about hours is looked into”. He was equally clear that the additional hours were not some rogue freelancing exercise: “During March and April, the restaurant depended on her to stay open, and she was told that staffing allowed her no days off. These additional hours were plainly required.”

The tribunal also found that Ms Schmiedel had been denied her legal entitlement to an uninterrupted rest period of at least 24 hours in every seven-day period, again because, she was told, there were simply not enough staff to cover her days off.

## The Award

Advocate Whelan’s findings translated into a substantial financial penalty for the restaurant. Ms Schmiedel was awarded £2,572.20 for unpaid hours in April, £356.50 for unpaid hours in May, and £882.48 representing the deductions taken from her March wages that were never passed to Revenue Jersey. She also received £2,170 in compensatory rest payments, equivalent to four weeks’ pay, for the denial of her weekly rest entitlement.

The largest element of the award came from the finding of constructive unfair dismissal. The tribunal awarded £14,105 representing 26 weeks’ pay, then uplifted that figure by 10 per cent to reflect the “evident distress” caused to Ms Schmiedel. A further £2,170 was added for unlawful dismissal, bringing the total to £24,667.23.

Advocate Whelan was pointed in his conclusion: “The company’s conduct was unreasonable. It held back all of an employee’s earned pay, including the hours it accepted were owed, while it looked into a dispute about hours, and it kept money deducted for tax.” He added that he could not overlook the distress suffered by Ms Schmiedel as she pursued what was owed to her simply to meet her rent and living costs, stress that eventually left her, by medical certificate, too ill to continue working for a period.

## The NSFW Perspective

There is something particularly grim about an employer who not only fails to pay wages but also holds on to tax deductions that were never his to keep. Revenue Jersey will presumably have views on that. The WhatsApp messages described in the tribunal judgement paint a vivid picture: a lone employee keeping a restaurant afloat, seven days a week, chasing the owner for money to pay the delivery drivers while suppliers cut off the accounts. Jersey’s employment tribunal system exists precisely for situations like this, and on this occasion it appears to have done its job. Whether the restaurant can actually meet a bill of over £24,000 is, of course, quite another matter.

*Source: [Jersey Evening Post](https://jerseyeveningpost.com/news/2026/11/12/waitress-awarded-over-24000-after-restaurant-withholds-wages)*
